Gradients = banding = aaaargh!!!
-
-
Oke this is seriously driving me insane....
I am having problems with dark gradients and banding... It's Friday and I am tired and simply can't think straight in order to bug trag this problem.
I have a dell monitor 2405 and this model is not known to banding in general.
In Photoshop working with 8bit RGB images I can make almost any type of gradient and no banding is present. If I look really close I might be able to find something that could look like begining to banding, but I think that's down to the nature of LCD monitors in general... But I would call my gradients nice and smooth.
But in EVERY vector program that I have tried it's not possible to make a smooth grey gradient - I always get loads of stripes nad banding. If I copy a vector element and paste it into Photoshop i can see it's a grey scale image and hence it will also look banded in Photoshop.
I have tried with Fireworks, Illustrator and InkScape - they all behave identical meaning loads of banding.
Going from white to black = banding
Going from dark grey like #333 to black = banding
I have removed "quick render preview / options" and similar - but no help at all.
If Photoshop would show bad banding I would just say it's the monitor, but due to the fine gradients I tend to think it's something else.. Exporting from Photoshop via web optimize tend to give me banding again though
Is there someting obvious I should check?
Would looooove some help on this.
Thanks in advance.
-
-
-
- Bob Ateah
- Elite Rocketeer
- Posts: 4521
- Thanks: 0
-
I tried Fireworks 4 and Fireworks MX and created a created a quick gradient that is attached.
I just have the default settings and i exported as a 24 bit png I don't see any banding.
Cheers and sorry that I'm no help. - The member formerly known as Roland Deschain
After your question is solved, please Edit your original post and choose the Solved message icon, thank you!
-
-
-
- Andy Miller
- Preeminent Rocketeer
- Posts: 9919
- Thanks: 96
- Web Kahuna
- Roland that image looks good to me... Thomas, you running 32bit display? Regarding 8bit, that will almost certainly result in banding as 8bit = 256 max colors, which is realy not enough, especially when viewed on a lcd monitor which can be kinda exacting when it comes to color boundaries.
-
-
-
Cheers both.. I feel I am getting mixed results in all this..
Roland your gradient does indeed look smooth on my monitor as well - how does these gradients look on yours?
Mines are def. showing some signs of banding:
Illustrator, FireWorks, InkScape and Photoshop
-
-
-
- GollumX
- Elite Rocketeer
- Posts: 2817
- Thanks: 0
- in my limited experience you can't escape banding with 8bit.
- Say no to Internet Explorer 6.
twitter.com/mark_up
-
-
-
Should not have mentioned the term 8bit
Everything is exported in 24bit png..
-
-
-
Could someone please make one or two gradients in png with the following colors:
#4C5866 --> #2C333B
#4C5866 --> #283524
For instance with the same dimensions as Roland posted.
-
-
-
- GollumX
- Elite Rocketeer
- Posts: 2817
- Thanks: 0
- 24bit PNG created on FW 8.0 (seems i have a little banding too, though it could just be my eyes)
- Say no to Internet Explorer 6.
twitter.com/mark_up
-
-
-
Cheers Gollum.. I see a lot on banding on those as well...
Hhmm so it might not be that wrong with me... Andy Mac users able to post the same?
-
-
-
Btw when opening FW 8 - the blue background in the UI is also banding on my monitor
-
Time to create page: 0.056 seconds