ya gotta love fan bois 
Um, here we go with the bonuses being labeled as the norm again. They aren't taking something away without returning something, you were never supposed to have access. So everything you have had until now was a freebie.
according to who exactly? you and the usual suspects? are you now the official spokesperson for RT? until something official happens we're going to just have to write this off as "wishful thinking" on your part.
We are well aware of how rampant is. I have worked in IT professionally for 10 years, been on the net since it started, and was pirating stuff when 'pirating' meant taking a pile of 5.1/4 disks around to a freind's house for the latest commodore 64 games he bought off the shady guys at the local flea market. So please don't talk down to me like I am some naive no nothing and you are some l337 h4xx0r, and we will all now suffer some horrible fate because we didn't agree with you.
oooh is this where we break out the tape measure and compare epeens? OMG I liek bought a tandy tx 1000 back in '86 and used to hang on the PCLink BBS. Funny how you so quickly turn 180 degrees into some kind of rabid defender of The Club. Just don't make the mistake of thinking 10 year old flame bait is going to work for you here. Nice supposition that I'm going the haxoring type though. that actually made me chuckle. Is this where I'm supposed to respond with "you're 12, you're fat, you're a virgin, you have no life, blah blah blah"?
But what you are proposing is to make it easier for pirates.
having access to a support forum is going to make what exactly easier for pirates? unless of course you mean it will be easier for pirates find out how to switch a menu style for the first time. hmmm... come to that, isn't Andy going to be promoting piracy with his new tutorials and by putting "how to's" in his template demos?
No. You were only interested in offering people who don't want to pay a monthly membership something more. Nothing you suggested offered the people who do want to pay the ongoing membership anything at all. Some of your suggestions actually reduced the value of the benefits of what they received (compared to one offs).
take off the bandwagon leader hat and go reread this thread. I suggested the option of buying one-of templates with paid support and continued access to template-speicifc forums, user-driven forums, for ex-club members (people who have actually paid to use RT templates). You act like I've spit in Andy's face and break down into a cackling maniac in the span of three posts. Just as I posed it to Mack, if you don't have a problem with what you get out of the Club, great... for you. But how exactly does anything I've proposed affect you adversely in any way shape or form? because you are certainly up in arms about something.
The group you tried to help incidentally is the one you belong to. So what you were really trying to do was get yourself forum access again for nothing. Don't try to make yourself sound like some hard done by Martyr suddenly.
I honestly think you ought to sit down calmy, take a stress pill, and think things over (obscure?). I guess I'm only thinking of myself when I wish for world peace because I don't like the idea of being shot personally too, right? Can you show me exactly where I was trying to play moses and lead my opressed people to the promised land? Joomla is open source, RTTC is commercial. RTTC benefits from the open source community (and aside from RTTC you see Andy's contributions all over the place). If you can't wrap your head around the idea that letting people have access to support from others in the community on something they paid to use doesn't hurt anyone and benefits everyone, then there's no hope for you. and no, I won't buy that you aren't bitter that no one donated for your freebies.
I had a lot of respect for you until this post where you suddenly got all spiteful, self flaggelating and angry.
I can assure you the feeling is mutal. but hey, enough about us, how do you think the guy who started this thread felt when a raging pack of obsequious fawning sycophants jumped him? hell, at least I know what I'm getting into to when I open my mouth here because I've seen the usual suspects in action before.
I am now out of this thread, as it is no longer constructive and I don't want to get in a sh!t fight. I suggest it gets locked, because nothing useful is going to come of it from now except flames by the looks.
of course, right? typical message board troll tactic. throw down flamebait and tell the mods to lock it down so you get what you really wanted in the first place... no one discussing the issue originally brought into the light by the thread starter. /golfclap
If I say Andy should send everyone who buys a 3-month membership should get a bag of M&M's sent to them seriously, what is it to you? Why the need to shut others down when the outcome has zero effect on you? Andy's a big boy and as I said before, it's his show. He will run it as he sees fit and what he has seen fit to do is to pay attention to this community (or at least the most vocal members). I can speak for Andy in this respect because he has said as much in this very thread. So ask yourself again, why do you feel this burning need to shut others down when Andy himself wants to see what they have to say?