Roeland_A! wrote:
It is almost the same as rokbridge, only it has some more capabilities in terms of jomsocial integration. The SEF functionality is however something to watch, since it may put a heavy burden on the database. It is instead of rokbridge a 'wrapped' forum. You may want to keep that in mind.
There are 2 options with the p8phh either "wrapped" or "standalone" running in standalone is pretty much same as rokbridge in a sense. with the wrapped mode it helps you to more tightly integrate it with your site. I did notice though that in wrapped mode there is more to add to help it integrate like some lines in the .htaccess . If you are wanting something more simple though i would definetly suggest rokbridge you can always wrap it yourself in a module in the future but you will essentially have 2 different sites and 2 different databases. yes with alterbrains you will merge your databases into 1 which can take time and if you are not comfortable with mysql or phpmyadmin then you may want to stay away from alterbrains version.
Personally I am liking Kunena more than phpbb3 but its not easy to transfer a 10 year old forum "that has been updated" into Kunena I have been looking for a simple solution with no avail. Eventually though as the new kunena for joomla 3 feels so much more tightly integrated into the site as well there is not a separate admin area for the forum.
For now I will continue to use the alterbrains solution with phpbb3 ... if anyone wants to point me to a converter I would be much interested...
But seriously if you can stay away from bridges you will be happier if your starting a brand new forum go with one that was made for joomla it will make your life that much easier.